ALT LIFEPODCAST

Episode essay · Episode 8

Is it toxic, or is it a tonic?

Self-loving decision-making, the pamphlet people hand you, and the boundary test, with Eilat Aviram.

In this episode I sit down with clinical psychologist, hypnotherapist and author Eilat Aviram to talk about toxic friendships. I came in with a question I think a lot of us carry: how do I know if a friendship is genuinely bad for me, or if it’s just triggering something unresolved in me?

Eilat teaches what she calls self-loving decision-making. Her starting point surprised me. Choosing the right people, setting boundaries and looking after yourself are skills. If you keep ending up in friendships that drain you, you probably learned a different skill set somewhere. The good news is that skills can be relearned.

Toxic means poisonous

Think about the word itself. Toxic means poisonous. So the question becomes simple to ask, if not always simple to answer: is it toxic, or is it a tonic? If you are consistently walking away from time with someone feeling low, smaller or drained, pay attention.

The key word is consistently. Everyone has bad days, and Eilat is clear that one-off moments are just being human. What matters is the pattern. She is just as wary of the opposite habit we have right now, of labelling everyone toxic and cutting people off the moment a friendship gets uncomfortable.

People come with a pamphlet

I told Eilat about a few friendships where my very first impression was, “I need to be careful with this person.” We became close anyway, and every one of those friendships ended. She wasn’t surprised.

“People come with a pamphlet. We read it, and then we completely ignore it.”

When we first meet someone, they show us who they are and what problems we’re going to have. Her advice is never to ignore a bad first impression. Your body often knows before your mind does. Tight skin, shallow breath, that frozen feeling of not knowing what to say: that is your nervous system flagging something, and she says not to override it.

She also shared research in which convicted psychopaths watched videos of ordinary people walking down a corridor and picked out who they would target, with disturbing accuracy. The flip side is that most of us can sense danger too. We just talk ourselves out of it. Her rule of thumb is to watch behaviour, not words: watch how someone treats children, waiters and dogs, anyone they think is less than them.

You can make a good friendship toxic

This was the part that landed hardest for me. Toxicity isn’t always the other person. If you keep over-giving, always paying, always making the plans, always saying it’s fine when it isn’t, resentment quietly builds. The friendship becomes poisonous to you, and you are the one who made it that way.

“Loving yourself and listening to your needs is the least selfish thing you can do.”

We’re taught that putting ourselves first is selfish. Eilat turns it around: if I’m not meeting my own needs, I come to you expecting you to meet them for me. As she puts it, you are 100% responsible for your 50% of the relationship.

The tango and the waltz

So what if you can see you helped create the dynamic, and you want to fix it rather than walk away? I asked this one for myself. When you’ve moved countries and cities, good friends are hard to find.

Eilat’s answer was a dance. If we’re dancing the tango and I start dancing a waltz, you can’t keep dancing the tango. You either step off the floor or you start waltzing with me. Change your steps, and the dance has to change.

That is also her boundary test. Set an honest boundary, something as small as “I always pay, how about we split it this time,” and watch whether the other person can flow with it. If they can’t, that tells you a lot.

Bears and snakes

We also talked about narcissism. Eilat describes two kinds: the bear, who you see coming a mile away, and the snake, who seems quiet until you step too close and then strikes. Either way, if you come near the flaw they are protecting, they have to take you down. They blame, shame, dismiss or ghost.

Why you freeze, and the key that reopens any conversation

I always have the perfect answer the next day. Eilat explained why. When your nervous system senses danger, the part of your brain that plans and comes up with clever replies goes offline, and your primal brain takes over. So buy yourself time: “I need to think about that. I’ll get back to you tomorrow.”

And if the moment has passed, she has a beautiful key. Start with “I was thinking about…” As soon as you say it, the conversation is open again. “I was thinking about what happened last Friday. Even though it seemed like you were joking, I actually felt quite stung by that.” Then wait and see what they do with it.

The question to carry with you

Discomfort, Eilat says, is a massive gift. It is your system asking you to listen. So the next time you feel reluctance or resentment creeping in, ask yourself the question she left me with:

“If I loved myself, what would I choose to do now?”

There is only one world expert on you, and that is you.

Watch the full episode