I didn’t know I was lonely until I wasn’t lonely anymore. That’s how I described my first years after moving to South Africa: feeling different, misunderstood, unable to really connect. Looking back, a lot of my struggles came from that.
In this episode I sit down with Dr Shiv Dawson, South Africa’s first integrative psychiatrist, to understand what loneliness actually is, what it does to us, and how we heal from it.
Loneliness, isolation and solitude are different things
Shiv starts by separating three things we often mix up. Loneliness is an internal experience of not having meaningful connection. You can feel lonely in a crowd, or in a marriage. Social isolation is physical exclusion, like many of us experienced during COVID. Solitude is chosen, and it is restorative. She likens loneliness to grief: the same longing, the same sense of looking at the world without being able to inhabit it.
She points to Harvard’s 75-year study of adult development, which found the quality of our relationships to be the single most important factor in happiness, wellbeing and longevity. Chronic loneliness, she says, puts a level of stress on the body comparable to smoking fifteen cigarettes a day.
What loneliness does to the brain
Brain scans of lonely people, Shiv explains, show them perceiving threat about twice as much. The part of the brain that makes considered decisions has less say, and the emotional alarm system is more switched on. The network that thinks about ourselves, which she calls the Woody Allen circuit, starts ruminating negatively. A lonely person becomes more suspicious and guarded, and others can feel it and back away. That is part of why loneliness can seem contagious.
What helped most in the research wasn’t simply putting lonely people together, or giving them more therapy, or teaching social skills. It was helping people understand their own threat responses, how they were misreading eye contact and body language, so they could lower their guard.
That landed for me. When I feel disconnected, it physically feels like my heart is closed. And the closing is what makes connection harder, which then makes me feel rejected.
The parts of us we banished
Shiv’s explanation of where this begins was the most moving part of the conversation for me. As children, even with good-enough parents, some part of us wasn’t tolerated. We were too loud, too emotional, too angry. To stay close to the people we depended on, we split that part off.
“All these parts that we’ve banished have a place within us.”
But the banished part doesn’t go away. It keeps knocking. In adult relationships it shows up as discomfort, shame, a feeling of not being authentic, and a need to present ourselves as perfect. For Shiv, the fundamental cure for loneliness is understanding that this fragmentation happens in all of us, and being self-compassionate enough to look at it.
What shadow work actually looks like
I hear “shadow work” everywhere and wanted to know what it actually involves. Shiv described three parts. First, a meditative practice, so you can sit with the restlessness and notice what keeps arising. Second, looking honestly at the patterns that repeat in your closest relationships. She gave the example of her own marriage: her deep need for harmony meeting her husband’s passionate, outspoken nature, and the same friction coming up for twenty years. Third, being honest about where you are draining yourself.
Therapy can help too. In parts work, she might ask a depressed client to step into the part of her that feels depressed, and find out how old she is and what she needs. It becomes a kind of play, like the doll games we acted out as children.
Roots
Shiv also brought in the root chakra, the energy centre she associates with our earliest years and our sense of safety. Like trees, she says, the deeper our roots, the taller we can grow. It all comes back to belonging. Do you feel you belong to the earth? Do you feel you belong to yourself? Only then does it reach out to other people.
Solitude as medicine
As a young woman, Shiv vowed to surround herself with friends, to “peanut-butter layer” herself with people. Now, after years of inner work, time alone is what nourishes her most. She reminded me that great teachers have always withdrawn: the Buddha under the bodhi tree, Jesus in the desert, the Prophet Muhammad in the cave of Hira.
Her practical advice was simple. Spend hours in nature, in the ocean, the forest, on the mountain, repeatedly. And if your mind floods you with rumination, write down the themes. Our brains think the same things most of the time. Then ask: is this what I want to be thinking about?